Keller Williams Realty

Butler Tarkington Neighborhood Profile

Dated: 02/15/2018

Views: 204

Image title

Looking for a neighborhood that’s rich in history, architecture, and education? The mostly residential Butler Tarkington neighborhood is a place worth your research. Covering a span of around 930 acres, the neighborhood boundaries are the Central Canal and Westfield Boulevard to the north, Michigan Road to the west, and Meridian Street to the east, and 38th Street and Crown Hill Cemetery to the south.

What began as a farming area has now turned into a neighborhood of attractive residential properties. Amongst these homes, the neighborhood is home to the Indiana Governor’s Mansion, William N. Thompson House, and other prime examples of examples of Tudor Revival, Colonial Revival, and Classical Revival style architecture. In addition to these beautiful homes, most households are made up of working to upper-middle-class households of various demographic backgrounds.


Within an easy driving distance, there are plenty of things to do in the neighborhood! The area is home to the Indiana State Fairgrounds, where numerous events happen every year. Visiting the nearby Indianapolis Museum of Art and The Children’s Museum of Indianapolis are also an easy venture for those living in the Butler Tarkington Neighborhood.

On the border of the neighborhood is Crown Hill Cemetery. The privately owned cemetery is the final resting place to several notable people, such as Benjamin Harrison, James Whitcomb Riley, John Dillinger, Alexander Ralston, and May Wright Sewell. The cemetery is also filled with an abundance of trees and wildlife. Birds, white-tailed deer, and other small animals have found refuge on the grounds.

Also found nearby are the Monon Trail and Central Canal Towpath. These pathways are great for running, walking, or bike riding. These trails also run to other popular Indy neighborhood and attractions.


Along the 38th Street corridor, you’ll find plenty of fast food and convenience store options. Head a little further north to the intersection of 56th & Illinois to support the small businesses of the neighborhood.

Whatever you’re looking for, the Shoppes at 56th & Illinois have something for everyone. Visit Charles Mayer & Company for elegant and modern gifts, Kincaid’s Meat Market for fine cuts of meat, or Petite G Jewelers for fine jewelry. You can visit Be the Boutique or The Secret Ingredient for women’s clothes, a Graeter’s Ice Cream for some of the tastiest handcrafted ice cream, and Kids Ink Bookstore for your children’s books! Not to mention several nearby grocery (Safeway, Kroger, Meijer) and CVS Pharmacy options.

With plentiful educational options closeby - public and private, this neighborhood continues to bring in families of all kinds. Single family homes, apartments, and condominiums continue to draw new residents every day to this central corridor of the city.

Want to Advertise on this Site?

Latest Blog Posts

Neighborhood Profile Irvington

This small pocket neighborhood on Indianapolis' east side continues to grow. This historic neighborhood thrives on quirky architecture, old buildings, and the brick-lined streets. What was

Read More

What The Seller Says About 2120 Wynnedale Rd

What are features of your home that you've really enjoyed?We fell in love with the property because of the large, private yard. You really feel like you’re sitting in the country when downtown

Read More

Neighborhood Profile Fountain Square

Fountain Square lies just southeast of the Mile Square of downtown Indianapolis. What was once a vibrant commercial district saw a major decline in the 1970s. In 2018, the neighborhood has been

Read More

Neighborhood Profile Indianapolis Old Northside

The Old Northside of Indianapolis used to be one of the most fashionable places to live in Indianapolis during the time surrounding the American Civil War. After a slow decline during the 1950s and

Read More